RE: order of covariate inclusion -> avoiding stepwise approaches -> abandoning exploratory analysis?

From: Mark Sale Date: September 26, 2003 technical Source: cognigencorp.com
From: mark.e.sale@gsk.com Subject: RE: [NMusers] order of covariate inclusion -> avoiding stepwise approaches -> abandoning exploratory analysis? Date: 9/26/2003 11:48 AM Bill, I have to agree. At the risk of being accused of being a frequentist, the Bayesian view can be taken too far. (collective gasp!!!). But, the reality is that we are often (usually??) wrong about our models, that why we do studies. We shouldn't (yet) complete discard the old "scientific method" of hypothesis generation - data - hypothesis test/new hypothesis generation. The learn/confirm view is frequently more like GenerateHypothesis Convince oneself that hypothesis is true CompletePhD age = 30 Do while not (hypothesis = true) GetData age = age + 1 Data suggests hypothesis isn't true if age > 99 then exit end do end Those in academics should add a call to WriteGrant inside the do loop Mark
Sep 25, 2003 Peter Bonate order of covariate inclusion
Sep 25, 2003 Leonid Gibiansky Re: order of covariate inclusion
Sep 25, 2003 Peter Bonate Re: order of covariate inclusion
Sep 25, 2003 Leonid Gibiansky Re: order of covariate inclusion
Sep 25, 2003 Harry Mager Hm Re: order of covariate inclusion
Sep 25, 2003 William Bachman RE: Re: order of covariate inclusion
Sep 25, 2003 Leonid Gibiansky RE: Re: order of covariate inclusion
Sep 25, 2003 Peter Bonate RE: Re: order of covariate inclusion
Sep 25, 2003 Kenneth Kowalski RE: order of covariate inclusion
Sep 25, 2003 Alan Xiao RE: Re: order of covariate inclusion
Sep 25, 2003 Leonid Gibiansky Re: order of covariate inclusion
Sep 25, 2003 Kenneth Kowalski RE: order of covariate inclusion
Sep 25, 2003 Sduffull RE: order of covariate inclusion
Sep 25, 2003 Marc Gastonguay RE: order of covariate inclusion -> avoiding stepwise approaches
Sep 26, 2003 Gary Maier RE: order of covariate inclusion -> avoiding stepwise approaches
Sep 26, 2003 Marc Gastonguay RE: order of covariate inclusion -> avoiding stepwise approaches
Sep 26, 2003 William Bachman RE: order of covariate inclusion -> avoiding stepwise approaches -> abandoning exploratory analysis?
Sep 26, 2003 Jakob Ribbing RE: order of covariate inclusion -> avoiding stepwise approaches
Sep 26, 2003 Mark Sale RE: order of covariate inclusion -> avoiding stepwise approaches
Sep 26, 2003 Chuanpu 2 Hu RE: order of covariate inclusion -> avoiding stepwise a pproaches -> abandoning exploratory analysis?
Sep 26, 2003 Kenneth Kowalski RE: order of covariate inclusion -> avoiding stepwise approaches
Sep 26, 2003 Kenneth Kowalski RE: order of covariate inclusion -> avoiding stepwise approaches -> abandoning exploratory analysis?
Sep 26, 2003 William Bachman RE: order of covariate inclusion -> avoiding stepwise approaches -> abandoning exploratory analysis?
Sep 26, 2003 Marc Gastonguay RE: order of covariate inclusion -> avoiding stepwise approaches -> abandoning exploratory analysis?
Sep 26, 2003 Kenneth Kowalski RE: order of covariate inclusion -> avoiding stepwise approaches -> abandoning exploratory analysis?
Sep 26, 2003 William Bachman RE: order of covariate inclusion -> avoiding stepwise approaches -> abandoning exploratory analysis?
Sep 26, 2003 Mark Sale RE: order of covariate inclusion -> avoiding stepwise approaches -> abandoning exploratory analysis?
Sep 26, 2003 Marc Gastonguay RE: order of covariate inclusion -> avoiding stepwise approaches -> abandoning exploratory analysis?
Sep 26, 2003 David Garbutt RE: order of covariate inclusion -> avoiding stepwise approaches -> abandoning exploratory analysis?
Sep 26, 2003 Leonid Gibiansky RE: order of covariate inclusion -> avoiding stepwise approaches -> abandoning exploratory analysis?
Sep 26, 2003 Mark Sale RE: order of covariate inclusion -> avoiding stepwise approaches -> abandoning exploratory analysis?
Sep 26, 2003 Marc Gastonguay RE: order of covariate inclusion -> avoiding stepwise approaches -> abandoning exploratory analysis?
Sep 26, 2003 Sduffull RE: order of covariate inclusion -> avoiding stepwise a pproaches -> abandoning exploratory analysis?
Sep 27, 2003 Marc Gastonguay RE: order of covariate inclusion -> avoiding stepwise approaches -> abandoning exploratory analysis?
Sep 29, 2003 Mark Sale RE: order of covariate inclusion -> avoiding stepwise approaches -> abandoning exploratory analysis?
Sep 29, 2003 Harry Mager Hm RE: order of covariate inclusion -> avoiding stepwise approaches -> abandoning exploratory analysis?
Sep 29, 2003 Kenneth Kowalski RE: order of covariate inclusion -> avoiding stepwise approaches -> abandoning exploratory analysis?
Sep 29, 2003 Tgordi RE: order of covariate inclusion -> avoiding stepwise approaches -> abandoning exploratory analysis?
Sep 29, 2003 Leonid Gibiansky RE: order of covariate inclusion -> avoiding stepwise a pproaches -> abandoning exploratory analysis?
Sep 29, 2003 Guzy RE: order of covariate inclusion -> avoiding stepwise a pproaches -> abandoning exploratory analysis?
Sep 29, 2003 Mark Sale RE: order of covariate inclusion -> avoiding stepwise a pproaches -> abandoning exploratory analysis?
Sep 29, 2003 Kenneth Kowalski RE: order of covariate inclusion -> avoiding stepwise a pproaches -> abandoning exploratory analysis?