NMVI and SEs assessment
Dear NMusers,
I have questions about bootstraping and NONMEM VI assement of SEs.
I have developed a 2-compartment PK model using NMVI that converged with estimations of THETAs and OMEGAs. The predictive check simulations indicated that the model satisfactorily described the data with parameters estimated by NMVI. Then I started the assement of SEs by boostrating the data using WFN (1000 resamplings). I found similar results for THETAs, OMEGAs and SIGMAs (mixt error used). About the results of SEs, I also found similar results for the SEs of THETA1 (Volume), THETA2 (Clearance), OMEGAs and SIGMA1 (proportional part), but not for the SEs of THETA3 nor THETA4 (K12 and K21) and the SIGMA2 (residual error). I think that the actual values are more close of those obtained with bootstrap than those obtained with NMVI.
The results of the obtained SEs are described in the table below. I also performed a run with the same Input and data set with NMV and the results are also described in the table (NMV gives same results for thetas, omegas, sigmas and OFV).
SE of: NMVI values Bootstrap values NMV values
THETA1 0.148 0.154 0.154
THETA2 0.00218 0.00242 0.0227
THETA3 /*0.00063 0.0013 0.0013*/
THETA4 /*0.00036 0.0022 0.0019*/
OMEGA1 0.0094 0.0095 0.0094
OMEGA2 0.0050 0.0054 0.0051
SIGMA1 0.0063 0.0064 0.0064
SIGMA2 /* 0.675 0.946 0.832*/
My questions are:
- Why NMVI gives evaluations of SE less reliable than NMV ? and why only for THETA3, THETA4 and SIGMA 1
- for covariates determination wiht NMVI, do I need to perform bootstrap for each covariate or taking into account the decrease of omega is sufficient ?
- The value of residual error obtained with NMVI is 1.69 (SE = 0.675). The value obtained with boostrap is 1.58 (SE = 0.95), thus zero is included in IC95. How interpreting residual error including zero in IC95 with boostrap but not with NMVI. Removing SIGMA2 leads to failure of the run. Should I fix this value or leaving it with its SE ?
Bernard Royer
Pharmacology Dpt
University Hospital
Besancon, France